Skip Navigation Links

Case Summary

MICHELLE BODENSHOK NFA 11BCC00041 NFA ID: 0063465

Respondent/Effective Date Summary
 NFA IDRespondentEffective Date
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLE05/14/2012
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITH05/14/2012
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INC05/14/2012
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACY04/09/2012
Rule Summary
 NFA IDRespondentRule Type
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLE• C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITH• C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INC• C.R.2-9(c) - ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING PROGRAM
  • C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACY• C.R.2-8 - FAILURE TO MAINTAIN PROCEDURES
  • C.R.2-4 - HIGH STDS. OF COMMERCIAL HONOR
  • C.R.2-2(c) - FALSE REPORTS MADE TO A CUSTOMER
  • C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
Committee Summary
 NFA IDRespondentCommittee
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLE• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITH• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INC• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACY• HEARING COMMITTEE
  • BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
Action Summary
 NFA IDRespondentAction Types
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLE• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITH• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INC• GENERAL CONDUCT
  • OFFICE RECORDKEEPING
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACY• SALES PRACTICE
  • GENERAL CONDUCT
  • OFFICE RECORDKEEPING
Penalty/Event Summary
 NFA IDRespondentPenalty/EventEvent Date
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLE• OTHER--SEE NARRATIVE04/27/2012
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITH• FINE (JOINTLY AND SEVERALLY) $10000004/27/2012
  • OTHER--SEE NARRATIVE04/27/2012
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INC• FINE (JOINTLY AND SEVERALLY) $10000004/27/2012
  • OTHER--SEE NARRATIVE04/27/2012
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACY• PERMANENT BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP03/22/2012
  • PERMANENT BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP03/22/2012
  • PERMANENT BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS03/22/2012
Narrative Summary
Narrative for 0063465 - BODENSHOK, MICHELLE
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 23, 2011, NFA issued a Complaint charging Russo with deceiving commodity futures customers; making false reports to customers; exercising discretion without written authority; and failing to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade. The Complaint charged OFI with failing to implement an adequate AML program. Finally, the Complaint charged OFI, Malman and Bodenshok with failing to supervise.

ANSWER:

On January 19, 2012, OFI, Malman and Bodenshok filed an Answer to the Complaint in which they denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On April 27, 2012, pursuant to a settlement offer submitted by OFI, Malman and Bodenshok, OFI and Malman were ordered to be jointly and severally liable for the payment of a $100,000 fine. OFI and Malman were also ordered to adopt and execute specific undertakings related to: reviewing commission-to equity ratios on a firm-wide and individual account basis for compliance with NFA Requirements and taking appropriate remedial action in the event that such action is warranted; and implementing procedures to ensure that customer contacts are made in a manner that is subject to supervision by OFI. Bodenshok was ordered, for two years from the date of the Decision, not to be employed in a compliance related capacity by any NFA Member unless her compliance related duties are supervised.

Further, at NFA's request, Count III of the Complaint was dismissed.

 
Narrative for 0193293 - MALMAN, HOWARD KEITH
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 23, 2011, NFA issued a Complaint charging Russo with deceiving commodity futures customers; making false reports to customers; exercising discretion without written authority; and failing to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade. The Complaint charged OFI with failing to implement an adequate AML program. Finally, the Complaint charged OFI, Malman and Bodenshok with failing to supervise.

ANSWER:

On January 19, 2012, OFI, Malman and Bodenshok filed an Answer to the Complaint in which they denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On April 27, 2012, pursuant to a settlement offer submitted by OFI, Malman and Bodenshok, OFI and Malman were ordered to be jointly and severally liable for the payment of a $100,000 fine. OFI and Malman were also ordered to adopt and execute specific undertakings related to: reviewing commission-to equity ratios on a firm-wide and individual account basis for compliance with NFA Requirements and taking appropriate remedial action in the event that such action is warranted; and implementing procedures to ensure that customer contacts are made in a manner that is subject to supervision by OFI. Bodenshok was ordered, for two years from the date of the Decision, not to be employed in a compliance related capacity by any NFA Member unless her compliance related duties are supervised.

Further, at NFA's request, Count III of the Complaint was dismissed.

 
Narrative for 0371672 - OLYMPUS FUTURES INC
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 23, 2011, NFA issued a Complaint charging Russo with deceiving commodity futures customers; making false reports to customers; exercising discretion without written authority; and failing to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade. The Complaint charged OFI with failing to implement an adequate AML program. Finally, the Complaint charged OFI, Malman and Bodenshok with failing to supervise.

ANSWER:

On January 19, 2012, OFI, Malman and Bodenshok filed an Answer to the Complaint in which they denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On April 27, 2012, pursuant to a settlement offer submitted by OFI, Malman and Bodenshok, OFI and Malman were ordered to be jointly and severally liable for the payment of a $100,000 fine. OFI and Malman were also ordered to adopt and execute specific undertakings related to: reviewing commission-to equity ratios on a firm-wide and individual account basis for compliance with NFA Requirements and taking appropriate remedial action in the event that such action is warranted; and implementing procedures to ensure that customer contacts are made in a manner that is subject to supervision by OFI. Bodenshok was ordered, for two years from the date of the Decision, not to be employed in a compliance related capacity by any NFA Member unless her compliance related duties are supervised.

Further, at NFA's request, Count III of the Complaint was dismissed.

 
Narrative for 0354706 - RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACY
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 23, 2011, NFA issued a Complaint charging Russo with deceiving commodity futures customers; making false reports to customers; exercising discretion without written authority; and failing to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade. The Complaint charged OFI with failing to implement an adequate AML program. Finally, the Complaint charged OFI, Malman and Bodenshok with failing to supervise.

ANSWER:

On January 23, 2012, Russo filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On March 22, 2012, pursuant to a settlement offer submitted by Russo, he was ordered not to apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member at any time in the future.

 
Case Documents Summary
 NFA IDRespondentDocument Type
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLEANSWER
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLECOMPLAINT
 0063465BODENSHOK, MICHELLEDECISION
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITHANSWER
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITHCOMPLAINT
 0193293MALMAN, HOWARD KEITHDECISION
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INCANSWER
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INCCOMPLAINT
 0371672OLYMPUS FUTURES INCDECISION
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACYANSWER
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACYCOMPLAINT
 0354706RUSSO, JOSHUA THOMAS JACYDECISION
 
NFA is the premier independent provider of efficient and innovative regulatory programs that safeguard the integrity of the futures markets.