Skip Navigation Links

Case Summary

FRANK MICHAEL VECCHIO NFA 07BCC00047 NFA ID: 0080172

Respondent/Effective Date Summary
 NFA IDRespondentEffective Date
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAY11/28/2008
 0346967COMTRUST INC11/28/2008
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARD04/07/2009
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERT04/25/2008
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAH11/28/2008
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI G11/28/2008
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHA11/28/2008
 0205587MEHLER, STUART A11/28/2008
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVAN11/28/2008
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANK04/07/2009
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARK04/07/2009
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATION11/28/2008
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAEL02/21/2008
Rule Summary
 NFA IDRespondentRule Type
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAY• C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
 0346967COMTRUST INC• C.R.2-4 - HIGH STDS. OF COMMERCIAL HONOR
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARD• C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERT• C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
  • C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAH• C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI G• C.R.2-30(a) - MUST OBTAIN CUST INFO/RISK DISCL
  • C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHA• C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
 0205587MEHLER, STUART A• C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVAN• C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
  • C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-29(b)(1) - USE OF DECEPTIVE PROMO MATER.
  • C.R.2-29(b)(2) - MISSTATEMT/OMISSION OF FACT PROMP
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANK• C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARK• C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
  • C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATION• C.R.2-29(b)(1) - USE OF DECEPTIVE PROMO MATER.
  • C.R.2-30(a) - MUST OBTAIN CUST INFO/RISK DISCL
  • C.R.2-9(a) - SUPERVISION OF EMPLOYEES
  • C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
  • BLAW301(b) - REGISTRATION OF APS AS ASSOCIATES
  • C.R.2-29(b)(2) - MISSTATEMT/OMISSION OF FACT PROMP
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAEL• C.R.2-29(a)(1) - FRAUDULENT COMM. TO PUBLIC PROHIB.
  • C.R.2-2(a) - CHEAT,FRAUD DECEIVE CUSTOMERS
Committee Summary
 NFA IDRespondentCommittee
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAY• HEARING COMMITTEE
  • BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
 0346967COMTRUST INC• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARD• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERT• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAH• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI G• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHA• HEARING COMMITTEE
  • BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
 0205587MEHLER, STUART A• HEARING COMMITTEE
  • BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVAN• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANK• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARK• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
  • HEARING COMMITTEE
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATION• HEARING COMMITTEE
  • BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAEL• BUSINESS CONDUCT COMMITTEE
Action Summary
 NFA IDRespondentAction Types
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAY• SALES PRACTICE
 0346967COMTRUST INC• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARD• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERT• SALES PRACTICE
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAH• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI G• SALES PRACTICE
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHA• SALES PRACTICE
 0205587MEHLER, STUART A• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVAN• SALES PRACTICE
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANK• GENERAL CONDUCT
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARK• SALES PRACTICE
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATION• GENERAL CONDUCT
  • REGISTRATION
  • SALES PRACTICE
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAEL• SALES PRACTICE
Penalty/Event Summary
 NFA IDRespondentPenalty/EventEvent Date
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAY• TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • FINE $2000011/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 6 MTHS11/12/2008
 0346967COMTRUST INC• PERMANENT WITHDRAWAL FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP11/12/2008
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARD• PERMANENT BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP03/23/2009
  • PERMANENT BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS03/23/2009
  • PERMANENT BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP03/23/2009
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERT• TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 3 YRS04/10/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 3 YRS04/10/2008
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 1 YRS04/10/2008
  • FINE $1000004/10/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 3 YRS04/10/2008
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAH• TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • FINE $1000011/12/2008
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 6 MTHS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI G• TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 1 YRS11/12/2008
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 6 MTHS11/12/2008
  • FINE $500011/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 1 YRS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 1 YRS11/12/2008
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHA• TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 6 MTHS11/12/2008
  • FINE $1000011/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
 0205587MEHLER, STUART A• FINE (CONTINGENT) $50000011/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY WITHDRAWAL FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY WITHDRAWAL FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS11/12/2008
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVAN• TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 1 YRS11/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 1 YRS11/12/2008
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 6 MTHS11/12/2008
  • FINE $500011/12/2008
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 1 YRS11/12/2008
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANK• TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 2 YRS03/23/2009
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS03/23/2009
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 6 MTHS03/23/2009
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 2 YRS03/23/2009
  • FINE (CONTINGENT) $2000003/23/2009
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARK• TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP 6 MTHS03/23/2009
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP 6 MTHS03/23/2009
  • TEMPORARY BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS 6 MTHS03/23/2009
  • REQUIRED TO TAPE RECORD 1 YRS03/23/2009
  • FINE $1000003/23/2009
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATION• PERMANENT WITHDRAWAL FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP11/12/2008
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAEL• PERMANENT BAR FROM NFA MEMBERSHIP02/06/2008
  • PERMANENT BAR FROM PRINCIPAL STATUS02/06/2008
  • PERMANENT BAR FROM NFA ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP02/06/2008
Narrative Summary
Narrative for 0204981 - BURSTEIN, RANDY JAY
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Burstein filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0346967 - COMTRUST INC
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 21, 2008, Comtrust and Mehler filed an Answer to the Complaint in which they denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0183816 - GEE, DENNIS RICHARD
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Gee filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On March 23, 2009, Gee was permanently barred from NFA membership, associate membership and from acting as a principal of an NFA Member. Smith was ordered to pay a $10,000 fine and is suspended from NFA membership and associate membership and may not act as a principal of an NFA Member for six months. For a period of one year (exclusive of any period during which Smith is suspended or is not an NFA Member or an Associate Member), Smith may not be an Associate of an NFA Member unless Smith's sponsor agrees in writing to tape record all conversations that occur between Smith and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA. During the one year period, Smith may not be an NFA Member or a principal of an NFA Member unless that Member agrees in writing to tape record all conversations between the firm's APs and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA.

Santovito was barred from NFA membership and associate membership and may not act as a principal of an NFA Member for two years. Should Santovito be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of his two-year bar, he must pay a $20,000 fine, due and payable within 30 days after he is granted NFA membership associate membership or principal status. For six months (exclusive of any period during which Santovito is not an NFA Member or an Associate Member), Santovito may not be an NFA Member, a principal of an NFA Member or a branch office manager of an NFA Member unless that Member agrees in writing to tape record all conversations between the firm's APs and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA.

 
Narrative for 0220229 - GONZALEZ, ALBERT
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

DECISION:

On April 10, 2008, Gonzalez was ordered not to apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA member for three years. If Gonzalez is granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status after the three-year temporary bar, he was ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, due and payable 30 days after he is granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member.

Gonzalez was further ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for one year. Gonzalez shall also cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which he is a principal to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during the one-year period. Gonzalez must promptly produce such recordings to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which Gonzalez is an NFA Member or principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

 
Narrative for 0265753 - KAISER, MELISSA SARAH
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Kaiser filed an Answer to the Complaint in which she denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0195829 - LEVINE, RANDI G
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Levine filed an Answer to the Complaint in which she denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0341752 - MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHA
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On January 10, 2008, Marchetto filed an Answer to the Complaint in which she denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0205587 - MEHLER, STUART A
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 21, 2008, Comtrust and Mehler filed an Answer to the Complaint in which they denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0201649 - RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVAN
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Rautbord filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0061549 - SANTOVITO, PETER FRANK
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On December 12, 2007, Santovito filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Santovito filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On March 23, 2009, Gee was permanently barred from NFA membership, associate membership and from acting as a principal of an NFA Member. Smith was ordered to pay a $10,000 fine and is suspended from NFA membership and associate membership and may not act as a principal of an NFA Member for six months. For a period of one year (exclusive of any period during which Smith is suspended or is not an NFA Member or an Associate Member), Smith may not be an Associate of an NFA Member unless Smith's sponsor agrees in writing to tape record all conversations that occur between Smith and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA. During the one year period, Smith may not be an NFA Member or a principal of an NFA Member unless that Member agrees in writing to tape record all conversations between the firm's APs and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA.

Santovito was barred from NFA membership and associate membership and may not act as a principal of an NFA Member for two years. Should Santovito be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of his two-year bar, he must pay a $20,000 fine, due and payable within 30 days after he is granted NFA membership associate membership or principal status. For six months (exclusive of any period during which Santovito is not an NFA Member or an Associate Member), Santovito may not be an NFA Member, a principal of an NFA Member or a branch office manager of an NFA Member unless that Member agrees in writing to tape record all conversations between the firm's APs and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA.

 
Narrative for 0239238 - SMITH, STEPHEN MARK
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, Smith filed an Answer to the Complaint in which he denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On March 23, 2009, Gee was permanently barred from NFA membership, associate membership and from acting as a principal of an NFA Member. Smith was ordered to pay a $10,000 fine and is suspended from NFA membership and associate membership and may not act as a principal of an NFA Member for six months. For a period of one year (exclusive of any period during which Smith is suspended or is not an NFA Member or an Associate Member), Smith may not be an Associate of an NFA Member unless Smith's sponsor agrees in writing to tape record all conversations that occur between Smith and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA. During the one year period, Smith may not be an NFA Member or a principal of an NFA Member unless that Member agrees in writing to tape record all conversations between the firm's APs and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA.

Santovito was barred from NFA membership and associate membership and may not act as a principal of an NFA Member for two years. Should Santovito be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of his two-year bar, he must pay a $20,000 fine, due and payable within 30 days after he is granted NFA membership associate membership or principal status. For six months (exclusive of any period during which Santovito is not an NFA Member or an Associate Member), Santovito may not be an NFA Member, a principal of an NFA Member or a branch office manager of an NFA Member unless that Member agrees in writing to tape record all conversations between the firm's APs and both existing and potential customers; retain each tape for two years from the date the tape is created; and make the tapes available to NFA.

 
Narrative for 0244735 - UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATION
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

ANSWER:

On February 11, 2008, UCC filed an Answer to the Complaint in which the firm denied the material allegations contained therein.

DECISION:

On November 12, 2008, UCC and Comtrust agreed to withdraw from NFA membership and never again apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member. Mehler agreed to withdraw from NFA associate membership and principal status with any and all NFA Members and not apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Should Mehler attain NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member in the future, he agreed to pay a $500,000 fine, due and payable in full within thirty days of attaining any such status.

Kaiser, Burstein and Marchetto were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for two years. Levine and Rautbord were each barred from NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member for one year.

Kaiser, Burstein, Levine, Rautbord and Marchetto were each ordered to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers for six months. They were also ordered to cause any and all APs sponsored by any Member of which they are a principal during the six-month period, to tape record any and all conversations with customers or prospective customers during that period. They were also ordered to promptly produce any and all recordings required to NFA in a manner in which the participants and dates of the conversations can be readily identified. Only periods during which they are an NFA Member or a principal or an Associate of an NFA Member will be counted.

Should they be granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member following the expiration of their respective bars, Kaiser and Marchetto were ordered to pay a $10,000 fine, Levine and Rautbord were ordered to pay a $5,000 fine and Burstein was ordered to pay a $20,000 fine. The fines are due and payable in full thirty days after they are granted NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with an NFA Member.

 
Narrative for 0080172 - VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAEL
**TO VIEW DOCUMENTS, GO TO CASE DOCUMENTS. FOR A COPY OF DOCUMENTS, CONTACT NFA'S INFORMATION CENTER.**

COMPLAINT:

On December 5, 2007, NFA issued a Complaint charging UCC, Burstein, Gonzalez, Levine, Marchetto, Rautbord, S. Smith and Vecchio with making deceptive and misleading sales solicitations. In addition, the Complaint charged UCC and Levine with encouraging an individual to supply inaccurate financial information. The Complaint also charged UCC and Rautbord with using deceptive and misleading promotional material. The Complaint further charged UCC with allowing an unregistered individual to act in a capacity requiring registration as an AP. Also, the Complaint charged UCC, Mehler, Kaiser, Santovito and Gee with failing to diligently supervise employees and agents in the conduct of their commodity futures activities. Finally, the Complaint charged Comtrust with failure to uphold high standards of commercial honor and just and equitable principles of trade.

DECISION:

On February 6, 2008, Vecchio was ordered not to apply for NFA membership, associate membership or principal status with any NFA Member at any time in the future.

 
Case Documents Summary
 NFA IDRespondentDocument Type
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAYANSWER
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAYCOMPLAINT
 0204981BURSTEIN, RANDY JAYDECISION
 0346967COMTRUST INCANSWER
 0346967COMTRUST INCCOMPLAINT
 0346967COMTRUST INCDECISION
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARDANSWER
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARDCOMPLAINT
 0183816GEE, DENNIS RICHARDDECISION
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERTCOMPLAINT
 0220229GONZALEZ, ALBERTDECISION
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAHANSWER
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAHCOMPLAINT
 0265753KAISER, MELISSA SARAHDECISION
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI GANSWER
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI GCOMPLAINT
 0195829LEVINE, RANDI GDECISION
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHAANSWER
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHACOMPLAINT
 0341752MARCHETTO, ILEANA RACHEL NATASHADECISION
 0205587MEHLER, STUART AANSWER
 0205587MEHLER, STUART ACOMPLAINT
 0205587MEHLER, STUART ADECISION
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVANANSWER
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVANCOMPLAINT
 0201649RAUTBORD, SCOTT EVANDECISION
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANKANSWER
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANKANSWER
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANKCOMPLAINT
 0061549SANTOVITO, PETER FRANKDECISION
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARKANSWER
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARKCOMPLAINT
 0239238SMITH, STEPHEN MARKDECISION
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATIONANSWER
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATIONCOMPLAINT
 0244735UNIVERSAL COMMODITY CORPORATIONDECISION
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAELCOMPLAINT
 0080172VECCHIO, FRANK MICHAELDECISION
 
NFA is the premier independent provider of efficient and innovative regulatory programs that safeguard the integrity of the futures markets.